Post by Allison Harvard on Apr 18, 2013 23:39:35 GMT -5
Let's see how you did, ladies!
Emma
Commercial:
Editorial:
Katie: You have definitely selected 2 completely different photos. Your commercial is great, fun and shows a lot of energy! Your high fashion is very unique and I love the the fashion, setting and pose... I don't like your face... It's very blank and the lighting is terrible.
Allison: In terms of one being commercial and the other being high fashion, you did extremely well. Your commercial photo is very fun, fresh, and cute, I love it! Your editorial one is good in terms of it being an edgy, high fashion photo, but I agree with Katie. Your face isn't all that noticeable because of the sun's glare. Not bad overall, though! I think you'll be fine
Supernatural Supermodels with Jared Padalecki: Let's start with your commercial. I'ts very fun, sunny and bright. Makes me smile. I love everything about it for the theme. Then your high fashion. Bravo!! This is spot on!!! The styling is brilliant, the pose is unique. The lighting is a bit crappy but who cares. And I honestly dont' care about your face because High Fashion doesn't really care about expressions. Great job!!!
Twiggy: This is a great example of separating commercial and high fashion photo shoot. Job well done! I love your commercial photo, so appealing and lovely. Now, for your high fashion what not to love? I love everything about this photo except for the lighting which I think ruin the value a little.
Jensen: These are amazing I don't know what you did to improve since the first week but keep it up
Jessica
Commercial:
Editorial:
Katie: This competition is proving to be fierce! I'm completely fond of your commercial photo. I love your fresh face and your cuteness. Your high fashion is good, but lacking something or maybe giving too much. There is a clear difference between the 2.
Allison: This is good, Jessica. Really good. What I like about your commercial photo is that you seem very sweet and approachable, not just a crazy bundle of energy. I really love your high fashion photo too, the pose, the face, the fashion- it's stellar. I'm impressed!
Supernatural Supermodels with Jared Padalecki: WOW what can I say. Just like Emma, I don't think I can say anything bad. Your commercial is friendly and bright and just lovely and then your high fashion is magnificent!!! While I dont' mind Emma's face, yours is even better. It's fierce!!!
Twiggy: Bring it on girl, bring it ON! This is amazing. I'm blown away! Great job. I have nothing bad to say about either one, that's how good you did.
Jensen: I absolutely love both of these but I think it's expected from your celebrity in the right setting
Jennifer
Commercial:
Editorial:
Allison: I'm feeling deja vu from last cycle... this reminds me of Eva's pictures during this shoot. The problem I have, Jenn, is that I see more commercial in the high fashion photo and vice versa. Both photos are decent overall... but they fall under the wrong category.
Supernatural Supermodels with Jared Padalecki: I sort of agree with Allison and I sort of dont'. Your commercial photo is soft and light. While not giving us a commercial face, I see why you chose it. It's not high fashion and it reminds me of an advertisement. Your high fashion is too edgy to be commercial. It's a brighter photo but the high fashion appeal is there. I like these. You're very beautiful in both.
Katie: I love your high fashion photo, but not for high fashion... I wish it was your commercial shot. Your lips... Your arms.. Amazing!! Your commercial, isn't really commercial in my eyes. I'm just not feeling it.
Twiggy: I'm kinda iffy with this. But over all, I like both of your photos. Your high fashion is on the fence of being commercial. Its edgy but the value of commercial is there. Where as your commercial doesn't necessarily fall under that category, I'm feeling that fierce high-fashion value from your expression although pose and outfit doesn't really scream high fashion.
Jensen: I think the commercial I like a little better the ugh fashionis good but it doesn't pop to me
Katy
Commercial:
Editorial:
Katie: Who would have thought that Katy would have such great high fashion photos! It's amazing! You've captivated high fashion with an amazing setting. The issue I have is your expression... Your commercial is great.. Love your lips!
Allison: Wow, Katy! This is great! Your commercial photo is to die for... your lips are so luscious and perfect. It's captivating. It's one of my favorite photos of this competition (out of both seasons...). Your high fashion is amazing too. I love the fashion in it, and the poodle, and your pose. Katie's right, your expression is the one downfall of this. Overall, though, this is great!
Supernatural Supermodels with Jared Padalecki: OH THANK GOSH, the first photo for some reason was so fuzzy and distorted but it took a second for the photo to visualize or whatever lol
Your commercial is cute and bright. Like JLaw, your face is not that of a smiling wonderful face but it's gorgeous and commercial enough. Your high fashion photo is spot on!! The dress, the pose, the poodle, the expression. WOW, is all I've got left.
Twiggy: Would you like to work with Twiggy? come over to my office tomorrow and lets talk. I LOVE LOVE LOVE your submission this round, great work! Nothing bad to say about either photo except that your left hand, to me its kinda stiff and awkward.
Jensen: These are both really good I like the theme connection alot
Keira
Commercial:
Editorial:
Katie: I am not in love with either of these. I like the contrast of the two, but I am not feeling greatness...
Allison: This is alright, Keira, The commercial photo is very young and fresh, but it's bland. It looks more amateur than commercial. And the thing about your high fashion photo is that it SHOULD be great. It has a strong pose, it's very editorial... but the elements aren't coming together as favorably as they should be. This definitely isn't your greatest week.
Supernatural Supermodels with Jared Padalecki: I don't know sweetie. The commercial is good, it's over played but it's good. I like the sunny brightness to it but I've always found the way you're posed makes your face look so oddly shaped. Love the boots. Your high fashion is better. The outfit, the pose, I'm not in love with your face but your expression works. Not your best work for me.
Jensen: ............................ (I'm speechless)..........................
Twiggy: This is just okay. I like it but I'm not loving it. Your commercial photo is too boring and to me it looks more like an amateur girl trying to be a model. Your high fashion is better but your expression and outfit are killing it for me!
Reese
Commercial:
Editorial:
Katie: Reese... Reese... Reese... As someone who is completely familiar with Reese, I am utterly disappointed in what you have submitted. I know Reese's portfolio like the back of my hand. With that being said, your commercial photo is too busy and your hair is just too much for a commercial shot. Your high fashion is sorta boring for what you could have posted...
Allison: I appreciate that you took a risk in your commercial photo, but I think there are better photos than that one. You look amazing but it's not clicking for me. And yeah, your high fashion/editorial photo is a bore. You have so much potential but I feel as though it's not being reached here...
Supernatural Supermodels with Jared Padalecki: When I saw these before my first inclination was to ask you if you know of any Reese fansites for photos. I've only played Reese once but she's got a pretty good portfolio. I have yet to be utterly impressed by you hun. I'm saddened about this because you are one of my favourites. Everything the other two ladies have said is what I say.
Jensen: I'm kinda disappointed with this. There are good points in it an the are bad points in it.
Twiggy: I'm with the other judges on this. Pretty much underwhelmed, I'm expecting good things coming from you this round but this is just blah! Not buying it. You have so much potential but why this? This is b.o.r.i.n.g that's how boring this is!
Selena
Commercial:
Editorial:
Katie: WOW Selena, who would have thought?? This is great! I am amazed at how different your shots are. Your commercial is definitely something I'd see in a magazine advertisement. I love your smoky, sultry eyes in your high fashion shoot! Your jacket is perfect! Great job!
Allison: This is a very hit or miss week and I think you definitely hit this one. I like your commercial photo, it's very Seventeen Magazine, but what I don't like is that your smile seems forced. You look less approachable. Your high fashion one is far better, I'm in love with your eyes. Good job, Selena!
Supernatural Supermodels with Jared Padalecki: WOW, only a few of you ladies have wowed me this round and you're one of those few Miss Gomez. Your commercial is light and fun and just beautiful. Love the colouring, the pose and smile. Then your high fashion? WOWZA!!! Great job. Your eye contact is amazing!!!
Jensen (insert clever company name here): I like this all together I think the two photos compliment each other but at the same time they tell their own stories
Twiggy: Way to prove your worth Selena! This is fantastic, bravo. I love both photos! Who would've known a commercial face, like you could work the high fashion shoot? Nice job! I love your eyes in both, inviting!
Willa
Commercial:
Editorial:
Katie: Your high fashion is great! I don't like your eyes. The pose is fantastic! Your commercial is cute but seems more like a picture you'd find in a family photo album from a trip to the country.
Allison: Katie's on the money with this one. Your high fashion one is very high fashion, except your eyes make you look a little psycho. Plus this reminds me of your photo from "faux pas" week. Your commercial photo is cute but I don't see the modelling quality.
Supernatural Supermodels with Jared Padalecki: I just realized you're Kaitlin Cooper!!! Your commercial photo is how I saw it. I think you look cute and it's light and I see a touch of modelling there but a touch of your youth as well. This is the first time I realized who you were which is why I think it's a younger photo. Your high fashion is good, but familiar and I actually love the crazy eyes lmfao
Jensen:
WellThea Willa I like the high fangs ion one as Katie said your pose really sells that. The commercial one I'm kinda left wanting more on
Twiggy: For me both photos are spot on! I have no issue whatsoever with your eyes, its sooooo inviting and I would want to see more! I love your commercial as much as I love your high fashion. Amazing!
Yoona
Commercial:
Editorial:
Katie: Loving your commercial photo. Your pose is cute and you look like you should be in a magazine. Your high fashion is just a bit odd for me. I wish it were in color and I wish the quality were better. Your legs are amazing and the setting is great.
Allison: You made me chuckle with your gifset so props for that
work your catwalk, girl! Commercial is cute, but I'm not sold on the bag and the face. I think you could have done a better pose then holding up like it's a prize on a game show. You have a very seductive quality about you in the high fashion, your eyes stare into my soul it feels like. You did well overall 
Supernatural Supermodels with Jared Padalecki: Love the introduction darling. I'll remember you for sure. I like the commercial one, it's not as great as I'd like but it's almost there. The styling is nice. Your high fashion is great. The quality sucks but the photo itself is so amazing. The setting, the styling, the expression. Nice job.
Jensen: *bitch slaps jared* lol
I like the commercial one its got a nice feel too it. The high fans ion one seems a little dull to me I'd of liked it in color
Twiggy: You're someone who I would remember throughout this process definitely. What a personality! I like your commercial photo, I would want to buy that bag right away! Your legs are to die for in your high fashion photo, but there's something off about it. Maybe its because of the b&w touch to it or your face which I think you're giving us the same expression every week.
Thank you everyone! Waiting on a few judges to vote so expect elims tomorrow
Emma
Commercial:
Editorial:
Katie: You have definitely selected 2 completely different photos. Your commercial is great, fun and shows a lot of energy! Your high fashion is very unique and I love the the fashion, setting and pose... I don't like your face... It's very blank and the lighting is terrible.
Allison: In terms of one being commercial and the other being high fashion, you did extremely well. Your commercial photo is very fun, fresh, and cute, I love it! Your editorial one is good in terms of it being an edgy, high fashion photo, but I agree with Katie. Your face isn't all that noticeable because of the sun's glare. Not bad overall, though! I think you'll be fine
Supernatural Supermodels with Jared Padalecki: Let's start with your commercial. I'ts very fun, sunny and bright. Makes me smile. I love everything about it for the theme. Then your high fashion. Bravo!! This is spot on!!! The styling is brilliant, the pose is unique. The lighting is a bit crappy but who cares. And I honestly dont' care about your face because High Fashion doesn't really care about expressions. Great job!!!
Twiggy: This is a great example of separating commercial and high fashion photo shoot. Job well done! I love your commercial photo, so appealing and lovely. Now, for your high fashion what not to love? I love everything about this photo except for the lighting which I think ruin the value a little.
Jensen: These are amazing I don't know what you did to improve since the first week but keep it up
Jessica
Commercial:
Editorial:
Katie: This competition is proving to be fierce! I'm completely fond of your commercial photo. I love your fresh face and your cuteness. Your high fashion is good, but lacking something or maybe giving too much. There is a clear difference between the 2.
Allison: This is good, Jessica. Really good. What I like about your commercial photo is that you seem very sweet and approachable, not just a crazy bundle of energy. I really love your high fashion photo too, the pose, the face, the fashion- it's stellar. I'm impressed!
Supernatural Supermodels with Jared Padalecki: WOW what can I say. Just like Emma, I don't think I can say anything bad. Your commercial is friendly and bright and just lovely and then your high fashion is magnificent!!! While I dont' mind Emma's face, yours is even better. It's fierce!!!
Twiggy: Bring it on girl, bring it ON! This is amazing. I'm blown away! Great job. I have nothing bad to say about either one, that's how good you did.
Jensen: I absolutely love both of these but I think it's expected from your celebrity in the right setting
Jennifer
Commercial:
Editorial:
Allison: I'm feeling deja vu from last cycle... this reminds me of Eva's pictures during this shoot. The problem I have, Jenn, is that I see more commercial in the high fashion photo and vice versa. Both photos are decent overall... but they fall under the wrong category.
Supernatural Supermodels with Jared Padalecki: I sort of agree with Allison and I sort of dont'. Your commercial photo is soft and light. While not giving us a commercial face, I see why you chose it. It's not high fashion and it reminds me of an advertisement. Your high fashion is too edgy to be commercial. It's a brighter photo but the high fashion appeal is there. I like these. You're very beautiful in both.
Katie: I love your high fashion photo, but not for high fashion... I wish it was your commercial shot. Your lips... Your arms.. Amazing!! Your commercial, isn't really commercial in my eyes. I'm just not feeling it.
Twiggy: I'm kinda iffy with this. But over all, I like both of your photos. Your high fashion is on the fence of being commercial. Its edgy but the value of commercial is there. Where as your commercial doesn't necessarily fall under that category, I'm feeling that fierce high-fashion value from your expression although pose and outfit doesn't really scream high fashion.
Jensen: I think the commercial I like a little better the ugh fashionis good but it doesn't pop to me
Katy
Commercial:
Editorial:
Katie: Who would have thought that Katy would have such great high fashion photos! It's amazing! You've captivated high fashion with an amazing setting. The issue I have is your expression... Your commercial is great.. Love your lips!
Allison: Wow, Katy! This is great! Your commercial photo is to die for... your lips are so luscious and perfect. It's captivating. It's one of my favorite photos of this competition (out of both seasons...). Your high fashion is amazing too. I love the fashion in it, and the poodle, and your pose. Katie's right, your expression is the one downfall of this. Overall, though, this is great!
Supernatural Supermodels with Jared Padalecki: OH THANK GOSH, the first photo for some reason was so fuzzy and distorted but it took a second for the photo to visualize or whatever lol
Your commercial is cute and bright. Like JLaw, your face is not that of a smiling wonderful face but it's gorgeous and commercial enough. Your high fashion photo is spot on!! The dress, the pose, the poodle, the expression. WOW, is all I've got left.
Twiggy: Would you like to work with Twiggy? come over to my office tomorrow and lets talk. I LOVE LOVE LOVE your submission this round, great work! Nothing bad to say about either photo except that your left hand, to me its kinda stiff and awkward.
Jensen: These are both really good I like the theme connection alot
Keira
Commercial:
Editorial:
Katie: I am not in love with either of these. I like the contrast of the two, but I am not feeling greatness...
Allison: This is alright, Keira, The commercial photo is very young and fresh, but it's bland. It looks more amateur than commercial. And the thing about your high fashion photo is that it SHOULD be great. It has a strong pose, it's very editorial... but the elements aren't coming together as favorably as they should be. This definitely isn't your greatest week.
Supernatural Supermodels with Jared Padalecki: I don't know sweetie. The commercial is good, it's over played but it's good. I like the sunny brightness to it but I've always found the way you're posed makes your face look so oddly shaped. Love the boots. Your high fashion is better. The outfit, the pose, I'm not in love with your face but your expression works. Not your best work for me.
Jensen: ............................ (I'm speechless)..........................
Twiggy: This is just okay. I like it but I'm not loving it. Your commercial photo is too boring and to me it looks more like an amateur girl trying to be a model. Your high fashion is better but your expression and outfit are killing it for me!
Reese
Commercial:
Editorial:
Katie: Reese... Reese... Reese... As someone who is completely familiar with Reese, I am utterly disappointed in what you have submitted. I know Reese's portfolio like the back of my hand. With that being said, your commercial photo is too busy and your hair is just too much for a commercial shot. Your high fashion is sorta boring for what you could have posted...
Allison: I appreciate that you took a risk in your commercial photo, but I think there are better photos than that one. You look amazing but it's not clicking for me. And yeah, your high fashion/editorial photo is a bore. You have so much potential but I feel as though it's not being reached here...
Supernatural Supermodels with Jared Padalecki: When I saw these before my first inclination was to ask you if you know of any Reese fansites for photos. I've only played Reese once but she's got a pretty good portfolio. I have yet to be utterly impressed by you hun. I'm saddened about this because you are one of my favourites. Everything the other two ladies have said is what I say.
Jensen: I'm kinda disappointed with this. There are good points in it an the are bad points in it.
Twiggy: I'm with the other judges on this. Pretty much underwhelmed, I'm expecting good things coming from you this round but this is just blah! Not buying it. You have so much potential but why this? This is b.o.r.i.n.g that's how boring this is!
Selena
Commercial:
Editorial:
Katie: WOW Selena, who would have thought?? This is great! I am amazed at how different your shots are. Your commercial is definitely something I'd see in a magazine advertisement. I love your smoky, sultry eyes in your high fashion shoot! Your jacket is perfect! Great job!
Allison: This is a very hit or miss week and I think you definitely hit this one. I like your commercial photo, it's very Seventeen Magazine, but what I don't like is that your smile seems forced. You look less approachable. Your high fashion one is far better, I'm in love with your eyes. Good job, Selena!
Supernatural Supermodels with Jared Padalecki: WOW, only a few of you ladies have wowed me this round and you're one of those few Miss Gomez. Your commercial is light and fun and just beautiful. Love the colouring, the pose and smile. Then your high fashion? WOWZA!!! Great job. Your eye contact is amazing!!!
Jensen (insert clever company name here): I like this all together I think the two photos compliment each other but at the same time they tell their own stories
Twiggy: Way to prove your worth Selena! This is fantastic, bravo. I love both photos! Who would've known a commercial face, like you could work the high fashion shoot? Nice job! I love your eyes in both, inviting!
Willa
Commercial:
Editorial:
Katie: Your high fashion is great! I don't like your eyes. The pose is fantastic! Your commercial is cute but seems more like a picture you'd find in a family photo album from a trip to the country.
Allison: Katie's on the money with this one. Your high fashion one is very high fashion, except your eyes make you look a little psycho. Plus this reminds me of your photo from "faux pas" week. Your commercial photo is cute but I don't see the modelling quality.
Supernatural Supermodels with Jared Padalecki: I just realized you're Kaitlin Cooper!!! Your commercial photo is how I saw it. I think you look cute and it's light and I see a touch of modelling there but a touch of your youth as well. This is the first time I realized who you were which is why I think it's a younger photo. Your high fashion is good, but familiar and I actually love the crazy eyes lmfao
Jensen:
Well
Twiggy: For me both photos are spot on! I have no issue whatsoever with your eyes, its sooooo inviting and I would want to see more! I love your commercial as much as I love your high fashion. Amazing!
Yoona
Commercial:
Editorial:
Katie: Loving your commercial photo. Your pose is cute and you look like you should be in a magazine. Your high fashion is just a bit odd for me. I wish it were in color and I wish the quality were better. Your legs are amazing and the setting is great.
Allison: You made me chuckle with your gifset so props for that
work your catwalk, girl! Commercial is cute, but I'm not sold on the bag and the face. I think you could have done a better pose then holding up like it's a prize on a game show. You have a very seductive quality about you in the high fashion, your eyes stare into my soul it feels like. You did well overall 
Supernatural Supermodels with Jared Padalecki: Love the introduction darling. I'll remember you for sure. I like the commercial one, it's not as great as I'd like but it's almost there. The styling is nice. Your high fashion is great. The quality sucks but the photo itself is so amazing. The setting, the styling, the expression. Nice job.
Jensen: *bitch slaps jared* lol
I like the commercial one its got a nice feel too it. The high fans ion one seems a little dull to me I'd of liked it in color
Twiggy: You're someone who I would remember throughout this process definitely. What a personality! I like your commercial photo, I would want to buy that bag right away! Your legs are to die for in your high fashion photo, but there's something off about it. Maybe its because of the b&w touch to it or your face which I think you're giving us the same expression every week.
Thank you everyone! Waiting on a few judges to vote so expect elims tomorrow
